• Washington
  • Wall Street
  • A.I.
  • Hollywood
  • Media
  • Fashion
  • Sports
  • Art
  • Join Puck Newsletters What is puck? Authors Podcasts Gift Puck Careers Events
  • Join Puck

    Directly Supporting Authors

    A new economic model in which writers are also partners in the business.

    Personalized Subscriptions

    Customize your settings to receive the newsletters you want from the authors you follow.

    Stay in the Know

    Connect directly with Puck talent through email and exclusive events.

  • What is puck? Newsletters Authors Podcasts Events Gift Puck Careers
Welcome back to In the Room. I’m Dylan Byers. Greetings from New York, where I’ve been running another 72-hour source-meeting marathon, capped by Tuesday night’s book party for Kara Swisher at Bob Steel’s NoHo apartment, which he’s renting from Gary Cohn.
 ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ 
In The Room

Welcome back to In the Room. I’m Dylan Byers.

Greetings from New York, where I’ve been running another 72-hour source-meeting marathon, capped by Tuesday night’s book party for Kara Swisher at Bob Steel’s NoHo apartment, which he’s renting from Gary Cohn.

It was a treat to toast one of the true icons of this trade, and great to see so many of you in the same place: Steel, Cohn, Arianna Huffington, Phil Griffin, Andrew Ross Sorkin, Kevin Sheekey, Brian Stelter, Campbell Brown, the Zagats, Joe Kahn, Chris Licht, Bill DeBlasio, Katy Tur, Peter Lattman, Joanna Coles, Molly Jong-Fast, Betsy Lack, Oliver Darcy, James Bennet, Maggie Haberman, Sam Dolnick, Allison Gollust, Jon Karp, Kaitlan Collins, Stephanie Ruhle, my partners Bill Cohan and Jon Kelly, and Don Lemon & Tim Malone, who have finally set a date for their wedding. (By the way, despite the $24.5 million number you may have read about, I’m told by sources that Don’s big CNN payout, negotiated months ago, was closer to $20 million, which would reflect a roughly $6 million annual salary for the give-or-take 3.5 years still left on his contract.)

In any event, Kara’s 27-stop world tour continues this week in Washington with a Laurene Powell Jobs interview and a Friday-night party at Jim Bankoff’s place. I’m en route to L.A., but I’ll be back in D.C. myself in mid-March for Puck’s second-annual First Amendment celebration at the French ambassador’s residence, where we’ll be honoring Andrea Mitchell.

In tonight’s email, news and notes on the fallout from the ABC News restructuring, where Kim Godwin has taken an Al Haig approach to her effective demotion, finally asserting herself as a leader in an attempt to match the ubiquity of the network’s true boss, Deb OConnell. Unfortunately, and perhaps unsurprisingly, it’s already backfired.

But first…

🤯 Irreverent Vice: This morning, I received a cryptic and ominous email from a source at Vice Media, which recently laid off hundreds of staff and announced plans to shutter its website. “You wouldn’t believe how the Vice mtg just ended,” it read. “No way the C.E.O. survives.” It turns out that said meeting ended when C.E.O. Bruce Dixon took note of the “impossible to ignore” thumbs-down emojis that overwhelmed the all-staff Google Hangouts session as chief digital officer Cory Haik was speaking. Earlier in the meeting, Dixon warned that leadership “will not tolerate constant external leaks to the press moments after we communicate,” but of course that’s exactly what happened, and in part because Vice invited recently laid-off staffers to the live stream. (In a follow-up email Wednesday night, Dixon said the leadership still hoped to communicate openly with staff, but that “we are only able to do that in an environment that is respectful and professional for everyone.”)

For my money, the most confusing part of the meeting was Dixon’s attempt to bolster morale by suggesting that Vice News might one day become a sub-brand underneath CNN. As I reported last week, the CNN-Vice idea is a totally specious rumor being pushed by Vice’s owners to gin up interest, and there have been no real talks with CNN. Either way, I don’t know how long Dixon will be in his seat, but I disagree with the journalistic instinct that he’s a fleeting man. After all, the Vice job is entirely unappealing, and Dixon is incentivized to clean up the P&L by exiting staff. Management will back him to do the dirty work and suffer the slings and arrows in the process.

🦚 Mehdi Inc.?: Former MSNBC host Mehdi Hasan is the latest cable news personality to go it alone and brave the digital media business. The combative liberal commentator’s shows were canceled last fall, after which he claims to have raised $4 million in funding. Now, he’s launching a multiplatform channel on Substack (show, podcasts, articles) called Zeteo, from the Greek word meaning “to seek,” and will eventually charge subscribers $6 a month. Will it work? Ask Bill O’Reilly or Megyn Kelly. “It’s the equivalent of busking on the internet,” one veteran media executive tells me. “He has a fan base, decidedly small, and perhaps devoted enough to pay, [but] having an Ancient Greek name doesn’t make it another Axios—or a real business.”

🤝 Mattingly moves: Former CNN morning show co-host Phil Mattingly has struck a deal to become the network’s chief domestic correspondent, a savvy move by his representatives at CAA that likely positions him for future success at the network. Meanwhile, still no word on what’s next for Poppy Harlow…

🗣️ The week’s top talker: Adam Rubenstein’s “I Was a Heretic at The New York Times,” about—what else—the paper’s mishandling of the Tom Cotton op-ed. This really is the story that just won’t die. Blissfully, this post-mortem is quite a bit shorter than James Bennet’s recent opus. But it’s also a semi-tragic manifestation of the fact that, for some, Times Stockholm Syndrome has side effects that linger on long after they’ve left the institution.

What If Godwin Was One of Us?
What If Godwin Was One of Us?
Readouts from the new era at ABC News, where a recently layered Kim Godwin is suddenly more present and vocal than ever before, seemingly in an attempt to match the ubiquity of her new boss—all while acting like it’s business as usual.
DYLAN BYERS DYLAN BYERS
Over the weekend, ABC News president Kim Godwin sent an email to the network’s political unit, various producers, and on-air talent in which she declared that recent comments uttered by President Donald Trump about Black people were “as racist as they come.” Almost instantly, the assessment drew scrutiny from a number of ABC insiders who felt that a newsroom president shouldn’t make statements that could compromise the network’s reputation for impartiality, and complicate its journalists’ efforts to report on the former president’s campaign. “I hope David or George weren’t hoping to get a presidential debate this cycle,” one network insider said, “because that is now impossible.”

The statement, which Godwin made in an ongoing email exchange she’d initiated to discuss how to cover the former president’s recent remarks—he’d said his string of indictments were “why the Black people like me”—was the latest in a series of unforced errors that Godwin has made during her embattled tenure atop the network news division. And her missive was all the more notable because it didn’t even align with the network’s own editorial posture toward Trump’s comments. For its part, ABC News more cautiously characterized them as having been “criticized as racist.”

In any event, the scrutiny around Godwin’s remark came at a particularly inopportune time for her. After almost three years beset by criticism, she was effectively demoted earlier this month when her bosses created a new position for veteran Disney insider Deb OConnell that gave her oversight of the news division. Godwin had simultaneously (and somewhat unexpectedly) renewed her contract as network president for three years, but the implications of the restructuring were clear: Godwin had been sapped of her power, and the perks it conferred, and instead become what one network veteran insightfully described as “a general manager of the news division who doesn’t actually do the managing.”

Then again, many ABC veterans thought Godwin hadn’t done much managing to begin with. As many network insiders see it, Godwin’s latest misstep was actually an unfortunate symptom of her response to the restructuring. One of the frequent criticisms of Godwin is that she has been a hands-off leader who spends more time trying to manage her reputation than actually doing the job of managing the newsroom. In the process, she has often responded to perceived threats by hunkering down and enlisting the support of her loyalists or, in one memorable and notorious case, dispensing with critics by laying them off—moves that obviously have done little to burnish the rep or stanch the criticism. Indeed, one of the main reasons that talent and producers have welcomed OConnell is because she is exactly the opposite: a very hands-on leader who in her first weeks on the job has made a point of visiting every set, control room, and makeup studio, entertaining the talent, and keeping close tabs on the editorial product in a way Godwin never did.

According to the usual playbook, this is a moment when Godwin might try to rally loyalists to her side—and she may still be trying to do that. This week, I was told that several of the network’s Black anchors and correspondents had been invited to “a lunch for Kim” this Saturday at the home of Byron Pitts, the network’s chief national correspondent and Nightline co-anchor. When asked to comment, however, Godwin relayed via a spokesperson that she was not involved with the event. Of course, that left the invited journalists confused by what, exactly, they’d been invited to attend.

Al Haig Syndrome
More broadly, however, Godwin has responded to her demotion by taking the opposite tack—asserting herself as the network leader at the precise moment she has effectively lost that power. After initially going AWOL in the wake of OConnell’s promotion, Godwin has started showing up on sets and in the control room, and made herself far more outgoing toward talent and rank-and-file employees than at any point in the first three years of her tenure. “She’s visiting shows and teams she never visited before Deb got here,” one network insider said. And indeed, her decision to initiate an email thread about how to cover Trump’s recent remarks was another uncharacteristic initiative widely seen as an attempt to appear more hands-on and involved in the day-to-day editorial process. Needless to say, it backfired mightily.

As I’ve noted many times, Godwin began this job at a disadvantage. She entered an infamously cliquish and competitive network as an outsider and arriviste—and as the network’s first Black and first female president, no less. She was also given a mandate to change a cutthroat culture that many network veterans didn’t want to see changed, even if it had to be. The criticism of ABC News as a “wolf’s den” was welcomed by those who proudly self-identified as wolves. At the same time, Godwin’s conviction that she was being unfairly maligned by a coterie of nostalgic, grizzled detractors is belied by the fact that, even after exorcising those people, the cries of protest continue to come from inside the house. Meanwhile, the vast majority of people I talk to attribute ABC’s relative successes—ratings, bookings, etcetera—to the achievements of her predecessors or executive producers and talent who manage their own fiefdoms. In any event, many ABC News insiders don’t believe it will be possible for Godwin to see out the next three years of her contract.

Meanwhile, the relative optimism surrounding OConnell’s appointment betrays another longstanding anxiety of this industry. Across both broadcast and cable news, one of the most oft-repeated complaints I hear is that there are no more real leaders: no creative impresarios who actually watch the shows and care about winning big bookings and pulverizing the competition. Instead, the networks are mostly led by careerist manager types who are too busy prolonging the decline of the linear business (and, in some cases, their own climb up the greased ladder) to spend much time worrying about what’s happening on air.

When I hear these complaints, I can’t help but reflect that running a network news division used to be a calling and a final career destination. Now, it’s a necessary midcareer challenge for an ambitious fix-it executive type. OConnell is trying to be Roone Arledge as much as Cesar Conde wants to be Andy Lack. These days, these gigs are just stops en route to a corner office on a higher floor. After they take on Godwin, the wolves may just eat themselves.

FOUR STORIES WE’RE TALKING ABOUT
Baratunde on Biden
Baratunde on Biden
Pinpointing when Black voters began souring on POTUS.
BARATUNDE THURSTON
Schrödinger’s Streamers
Schrödinger’s Streamers
The five streamers least likely to survive the coming wave of consolidation.
JULIA ALEXANDER
Haley’s Donor Paradox
Haley’s Donor Paradox
Plus, details on Marc Andreessen’s “radicalization.”
TEDDY SCHLEIFER
MLB’s Pantsgate
MLB’s Pantsgate
The stupid and increasingly serious micro-scandal defining baseball preseason.
JOHN OURAND
swash divider
Puck
Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn

Need help? Review our FAQs
page
or contact
us
for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news.

You received this email because you signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with . To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.

Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 227 W 17th St New York, NY 10011.

SEE THE ARCHIVES

SHARE
Try Puck for free

Sign up today to join the inside conversation at the nexus of Wall Street, Washington, A.I., Hollywood, and more.

Already a member? Log In


  • Daily articles and breaking news
  • Personal emails directly from our authors
  • Gift subscriber-only stories to friends & family
  • Unlimited access to archives

  • Exclusive bonus days of select newsletters
  • Exclusive access to Puck merch
  • Early bird access to new editorial and product features
  • Invitations to private conference calls with Puck authors

Exclusive to Inner Circle only



Latest Articles from Media

Bari Weiss
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Bari’s Prison of Her Own Design
After a month of contentious delays, 60 Minutes finally aired its piece on the notorious El Salvador prison CECOT. The “hostage standoff,” as one person put it, ended in an uneasy truce that could have been reached a month ago—and without exposing the distrust and division at Bari Weiss’s CBS News.
Mathias Doepfner
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Politico Succession Games Begin…
An era at Politico has been ending for the last decade—at least since the departures of Mike and Jim, then Jake and Anna, and, of course, the sale to Axel Springer. But with John Harris ascending to the chairmanship, again, it’s finally Axel’s baby. And Mathias Döpfner may be looking outside the mothership for Harris’s successor.
Tony Dokoupil
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Tony and Bari on the Rocks
The sponcon set dressing at ‘Evening News’ provoked predictable outcry at the House of Bari. But are brand partners in TV news just an inevitability at this point?


Ben Smith, Justin Smith Semaphor
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Semafornication
Ben and Justin’s recent fundraise at an 8x trailing revenue multiple, which follows David Ellison’s extravagant purchase of The Free Press, suggests we’ve entered a new era of digital media valuations. Unless we’ve just reentered the old one. Anyway, is Punchbowl next in line?
Tony Dokoupil
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Tony Accords
Tony Dokoupil’s disastrous debut as anchor of CBS Evening News highlights the uncomfortable truth about Bari Weiss’s tenure: While her politics take center stage, it’s her inexperience that’s her real liability.
Jim Steyer
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Common Sense & Sensibility
A candid chat with Common Sense Media founder Jim Steyer on what lies in the hearts of Silicon Valley’s biggest bigwigs and what the A.I. bros are doing to your children. Plus, thoughts on Sundar, Zuck, and his brother Tom’s California gubernatorial bid.


Bari Weiss
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Weiss Flag
It’s tempting to view Bari Weiss’s first big blunder—pulling a 60 Minutes segment critical of the administration’s deportation efforts—as purely political, which it may have been. But it may have been the product of something more mundane: Bari doesn’t know how to lead a newsroom.


Get access to this story

Enter your email for a free preview of Puck’s full offering, including exclusive articles, private emails from authors, and more.

Verify your email and sign in by clicking the link we just sent.

Already a member? Log In


Start 14 Day Free Trial for Unlimited Access Instead →



Latest Articles from Media

Journalists
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The 2025 Media State of the Union
The inherent tension of the journalist-as-brand model, the continued erosion of institutional authority, the potential for an A.I. newsroom: Industry leaders weighed in on all this and more at a panel this week to unveil the results of our latest Puck–Orchestra survey.
Justin Smith ben smith
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Gulf of Semafor
As Semafor expands further into the Gulf, it’s becoming clear that Justin Smith and Ben Smith’s media baby is looking a lot more like the former than the latter.
Jim Lanzone Yahoo
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Lanzone That Time Forgot
Don’t waste your tears on Yahoo, the Internet 1.0 relic that collapsed into Verizon and then the warm embrace of private equity. C.E.O. Jim Lanzone explains how the Apollo-owned company is poised to make the most of its post-search distribution, and why niche is the new scale.


Bari Weiss
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
A Weiss Christmas
While The Free Press is flush with holiday spirit, Bari’s job reinventing CBS News is proving more vexing, amid anchor dreams dashed and the age-old challenge of enacting institutional change.
Bari Weiss
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
CNN’s Bari Christmas
In the wake of Netflix’s Warner Bros. coup, the folks at CNN are, perhaps naively, looking on the bright side: They may not have to work for Bari Weiss after all. But times in Spinoffville are going to get tough—and fast.
Olivia Nuzzi
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Nuzzicracker Ballet
The star-crossed saga of Olivia and Ryan continues its salacious, shameful pas de deux—ensnaring not just Vanity Fair’s new editor but further tainting journalism writ large. Even worse, it elides the real question: Why is a certain pathetic world hanging on every word of a jilted lover’s creepy account proffered without editorial oversight?


Hamish McKenzie, Substack
Julia Alexander • February 29, 2024
Substack Entrapment Theory
Google Zero killed the open web, ChatGPT isn’t replacing lost traffic, and superstar talent is a phenomenally difficult business. Digital media companies trying to stay upright are belatedly turning to creator-first subscription platforms in search of sustainable, niche audiences—without realizing that they’ve seen this movie before.
Get access to this story

Enter your email to get access to one article and free previews of our private emails from Puck authors and editors.

OR

Already a Member? Sign in



Latest Articles from Media

Alison Roman
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Roman Holiday
The internet’s favorite food author finds herself at a familiar crossroads for writers who have become brands unto themselves: trying to balance scale, new ventures, and authenticity while keeping a loyal audience fed… in this case literally.
David Zaslav
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Zaz’s Hollywood Endings
With the final bids for Warner Bros. Discovery under careful consideration, David Zaslav’s tenure as an ersatz Hollywood mogul may be coming to an end. Now, it’s all about the numbers, and which suitors have a glide path to regulatory approval. Just which sunset Zaz will ride into is anyone’s guess.
Olivia Nuzzi
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
A Brave Nuzzi World
Between the Bravo-ready mess of the Nuzzi-Lizza imbroglio and Michael Wolff’s Epstein deference, it was a monumentally bad week for media ethics. As journalists, even principled ones, become increasingly central characters in the stories themselves, is this kind of spectacle an unavoidable component of a new media world order?


Gerry Cardinale
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The RedBird Balloon
After a second bid to take over The Telegraph met a particularly British brand of resistance, RedBird Capital walked away from the whole ordeal. Now the 170-year-old paper is back to waiting for a Goldilocks buyer.
Jim Bankoff
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
The Bankoff Job
Jim Bankoff is considering a spinoff of Vox’s faster-growing podcast network from its legacy publishing business. While it makes economic sense-ish, what does it mean for the future of brands like SB Nation, The Verge, and… ‘New York?’
Stan Duncan
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
Stan By Me
A handful of disgruntled employees confronted Stan Duncan, Condé Nast’s H.R. chief, about the company’s decision to shutter Teen Vogue. There was a video, of course, which captures either a noble moment of employee solidarity or a bunch of entitled staffers willfully unaware of Condé’s dwindling fortunes and the realities of the legacy media business. Either way, how far they’ve fallen.


Mark Lazarus
Dylan Byers • February 29, 2024
MS Doom
Spirits are uncharacteristically high at the post-spinoff MS NOW, but this is still a late-stage linear operation that’s shedding (mostly geriatric) viewers at a steady clip. Despite Versant’s money and Rebecca Kutler’s ambitions, is it just a matter of time before the realities of cable’s decline drag them under?


  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Careers
© 2026 Heat Media All rights reserved.
Create an account

Already a member? Log In

CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Google
CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Google
OR YOUR EMAIL

OR

Use Email & Password Instead

USE EMAIL & PASSWORD
Password strength:

OR

Use Another Sign-Up Method

Become a member

All of the insider knowledge from our top tier authors, in your inbox.

Create an account

Already a member? Log In

Verify your email!

You should receive a link to log in at .

I DID NOT RECEIVE A LINK

Didn't get an email? Check your spam folder and confirm the spelling of your email, and try again. If you continue to have trouble, reach out to fritz@puck.news.

CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Google
CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Google
CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Apple
CREATE AN ACCOUNT with Apple
OR USE EMAIL & PASSWORD
Password strength:

OR
Log In

Not a member yet? Sign up today

Log in with Google
Log in with Google
Log in with Apple
Log in with Apple
OR USE EMAIL & PASSWORD
Don't have a password or need to reset it?

OR
Verify Account

Verify your email!

You should receive a link to log in at .

I DID NOT RECEIVE A LINK

Didn't get an email? Check your spam folder and confirm the spelling of your email, and try again. If you continue to have trouble, reach out to fritz@puck.news.

YOUR EMAIL

Use a different sign in option instead

Member Exclusive

Get access to this story

Create a free account to preview Puck’s full offering, including exclusive articles, private emails from authors, and more.

Already a member? Sign in

Free article unlocked!

You are logged into a free account as unknown@example.com

ENJOY 1 FREE ARTICLE EACH MONTH

Subscribe today to join the inside conversation at the nexus of Wall Street, Washington, A.I., Hollywood, and more.

START 14-DAY FREE TRIAL

  • Daily articles and breaking news
  • Personal emails directly from our authors
  • Gift subscriber-only stories to friends & family
  • Unlimited access to archives
  • Bookmark articles to create a Reading List
  • Quarterly calls with industry experts from the power corners we cover