The Michael Jackson Probate Mystery

Michael Jackson
This isn’t the first time the Jackson probate apparatus has faced a judicial reality check. Back in 2022, John Branca orchestrated the sale of Jackson’s catalogue to Sony for $600 million. When he sought Judge Mitchell Beckloff’s approval for the blockbuster deal, it triggered a challenge from the singer’s mother, Katherine. Photo: Kevin Mazur/WireImage
Eriq Gardner
November 11, 2025

Join Puck to listen to this article

Last Thursday, along with 116 million other Americans, I viewed the first official trailer for Michael, Lionsgate’s $150 million Michael Jackson biopic-musical, directed by Antoine Fuqua and starring Jackson’s nephew Jaafar in the title role. While others parsed the accuracy of Jaafar’s moonwalk, I had a different set of questions, starting with: Why is Jackson’s probate case still open 16 years after his death? Though the estate has become a commercial juggernaut—it has earned $3.5 billion since his death in 2009, according to Forbes’ 2025 list of “Highest Paid Dead Celebrities”—the legal machinery overseeing the entity has never actually wound down. Also: How exactly did executors John Branca and John McClain end up running a multibillion-dollar global brand out of a corner of the court system typically reserved for validating wills, settling debts, and parceling out leftovers?