Welcome back to What I’m Hearing, happily not coming to you from Comic-Con, the worst
place in the world.
🚨🚨 New live event! Join us for an in-person taping of The Town at the El Rey theater in L.A. on August 27 with a very special guest. (Longtime WIH readers will not be disappointed.) Tickets are here.
Programming note: I’m back on CNBC Squawk Box tomorrow at 7:50 a.m. ET talking Paramount, and then I’m on vacation
next week. (I know, not great timing.) Scott Mendelson and Julia Alexander will be ably filling in for me, and we’ve pre-banked some episodes of The Town.
Discussed in this issue: Will Smith, David Ellison, Hulk Hogan, Bari Weiss, Stephen Colbert, Graham King, Brendan Carr, Trey Parker, Adam
Fogelson, Anne Garefino, Ted Sarandos, David Zaslav, Ike Barinholtz, Shari Redstone, Kevin Morris, Connor Schell, Matt Stone, Ari Emanuel, Chris McCarthy, Bryan Storkel, Cindy Holland, Keyes Hill-Edgar, Edgar Bronfman Jr., Byron Allen, Taylor
Sheridan, and… Trump’s (allegedly) teeny-tiny penis.
Still not a Puck member? Just click here. Got a news tip or an idea for me? Just reply to this email or message me on Signal at 310-804-3198.
Okay, let’s begin…
|
- M.J.
movie holds the depressing stuff for part two: Graham King, producer of the much-delayed Michael, is still hoping for two Michael Jackson biopics, despite this week’s announcement that the first and only greenlit film will hit theaters April 24. As you’ll recall, the third act of Michael had to be rewritten and
reshot due to an overlooked settlement between M.J.’s estate and a child sexual abuse accuser. At the strong encouraging of distributors Lionsgate (domestic) and Universal (international), writer John Logan crafted a new version that takes Jackson through his rise to fame and fortune, culminating not in his downfall amid molestation allegations but in a Bohemian Rhapsody–style major performance that will leave the audience “happy and uplifted,” according to one source
familiar. The pedophilia claims that dogged Jackson during the final third of his life have been largely removed from the script. That path not only allows producers to trim what was a three-hour-plus cut of the film, it also leaves a big portion of Jackson’s life—some ups and many downs—as fodder for a possible sequel. Lionsgate could pull the trigger on that follow-up at any time—likely either when film chief Adam Fogelson sees the final cut of the first movie or even
after Michael opens—and Universal can opt in or out. The second movie would then probably shoot in the middle of next year and be released in 2027.
- The Hulkster died mid-documentary: Hulk Hogan, who died today at 71, will be remembered for mainstreaming pro wrestling and bringing down Gawker. He also left behind an unfinished docuseries on his life that Netflix has quietly been working on since last year, per sources. Director
Bryan Storkel and producer Connor Schell’s Words + Pictures have been collaborating with WWE and Hogan on the multipart series, which will include more than 20 hours of new interviews with Hogan that were shot before his passing. There’s no release date yet.
- Elon’s generous casting: No, Elon Musk probably doesn’t love that Amazon’s OpenAI movie cast Ike Barinholtz (The Studio)
to play him, rather than someone more famous or glamorous. (An intermediary for Musk asked me for the script, which I had written about; I politely declined to pass it along.) But besides the physical resemblance, Barinholtz is as smart as actors come. The guy won Celebrity Millionaire with his dad, and he made it to the semifinals of the Jeopardy!
Tournament of Champions. Not Celebrity Jeopardy, the regular tournament. Let’s see Elon do that.
- Box office over/under: The Fantastic Four: First Steps tracking rose a bit today (advertising works!), with NRG moving it to $115 million for the weekend. Some have it lower, so I’ll set the line at $110 million and take the over, based on good presales and the movie’s very cute baby.
|
Now on to the latest Paramount news, the backstory of that wild South Park episode, and Ellison’s planned
first big talent move at Paramount…
|
|
|
The would-be owner of Paramount scores the F.C.C. greenlight and survives the latest threat
to the deal via Trey Parker and Matt Stone, whose outrageous (and nude) parody of Trump comes days after one of the most contentious talent negotiations I’ve covered.
|
|
|
At this point, would anyone have been surprised if David Ellison and Shari
Redstone had preempted 60 Minutes to personally and publicly declare Donald Trump the sexiest man alive? The kowtowing leading up to today’s F.C.C. greenlight of the $8 billion Skydance-Paramount deal has bordered on comical. Set aside the $16 million bribe—sorry, settlement—of the bogus CBS News lawsuit, or Trump going on TV to claim the real bribe is actually more than double that amount. By the end, Trump and Brendan Carr,
his F.C.C. lapdog, were basically screaming Jump! over and over, with Ellison responding repeatedly, How high? When Dad agreed to buy David a Hollywood studio, it wasn’t supposed to be this… demeaning.
You fear “bias” at CBS News? How about a big role for Bari Weiss, the reactionary Substacker who’s never worked in TV news, and an ombudsman hired essentially as an anti-“woke” narc. You hate Stephen Colbert? He’s out.
Yes, the show was losing tens of millions of dollars, but if canceling Late Show happens to please the president, all the better. You want D.E.I. programs gone? Done. No matter that George Cheeks, the Paramount co-C.E.O. who is expected to stay atop CBS, personally mandated not that long ago that writers rooms for CBS shows be staffed with 50 percent people of color. That’s all over now. You’re welcome.
We’ll probably never know what additional promises
Ellison made or didn’t make to Trump, or what they discussed during those two private stop-n-chat’s during UFC matches, both orchestrated by Ari Emanuel and begging for an off-Broadway scripted adaptation by Aaron Sorkin. Trump first told us he’d been promised $16 million in P.S.A.s and other concessions. Then it jumped to $20 million. Ellison tells us nothing. Maybe this is all performative B.S. by the Trump people, a corporate version of sending the
National Guard to L.A. to quell an uprising that wasn’t real. Maybe Ellison and New Paramount will just ignore all these pledges once the deal closes. Regardless, the whole thing is pretty silly, and embarrassing, and, frankly, depressing.
And yet… Ellison is now on the brink of acquiring the asset that I first reported he wanted way back in December 2023. He and
Shari survived F.C.C. review by the most openly vindictive and transactional administration of the television age. Ellison may have lost some hair and part of his dignity—“capitulation over courage,” in the words of the dissenting F.C.C. commissioner—but he outlasted everything from Shari’s vacillations over whether to sell, to the Paramount board exodus and litigation threats (those aren’t over), to Charles Phillips and his alleged attempts to sabotage the deal, to “Project
Rise Partners” and Edgar Bronfman Jr. and Byron Allen and all the other suitor nonsense. This political stuff has been going on for a year now, since the deal was announced last July. And finally, after all that, Ellison’s gonna win a 100-year-old movie studio. A great business? Probably not, but not even the richest of rich kids have one.
|
Given all that, it’s a bit surprising—and, I suppose, a good sign?—that last night’s South Park
episode aired at all. Not that creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker don’t poke at the president regularly, and often in crude and outrageous fashion. But a naked Trump demanding sex from Satan? Multiple shots of the president’s “tiny penis” and an image of him violating a goat? A storyline involving a multimillion-dollar settlement of a bogus Trump lawsuit with explicit references to Paramount and Colbert, all culminating in an A.I.-generated Trump, sweaty and
nude, talking to his own penis in the desert? (The A.I. deepfake Trump was particularly brilliant, given that the same day the episode aired, the president announced White House A.I. policy positions favoring lackluster protections against exactly this kind of dangerous technology. It’s almost like Parker and Stone bought a company that creates deepfakes just for this moment.) All that was missing from the episode was a billionaire’s power-mad son trying to buy and enslave the whole town of South Park. But there are nine episodes left this season.
No, Ellison didn’t watch the episode in advance, per multiple sources. But he was given a heads-up that it was “disparaging” to the president. (Love the understatement.) Here’s how it went down: As often happens, Matt and Trey
were working on the show right up until the day it aired. (It was actually way more incendiary until some late trims, I’m told, and Stone said tonight at Comic-Con that they compromised by adding eyes to the penis so “it’s a character.”) South Park is typically reviewed by Paramount standards and practices, with an additional level of legal scrutiny. But for this particular episode, titled “Sermon on the ’Mount” (get it?), Parker and Stone’s producer Anne Garefino
flagged it to Paramount exec Keyes Hill-Edgar, who alerted Chris McCarthy, George Cheeks, and Brian Robbins. The co-C.E.O.s watched the show—no doubt knowing it would draw a rebuke from the White House just as the transaction neared the long-sought F.C.C. approval—and leaned toward airing it, but they decided to bring in Redstone. After the men described the episode to Shari (I’d pay good money for a recording of that
conversation), Redstone said she would back their ruling. “Shari Redstone had not seen the episode, so she told the C.E.O.s that she trusted their judgment and would support their decision,” a rep for Redstone told me. The verdict: Air it.
Predictably, the White House punched back this morning, though notably, Trump himself has not commented or posted about the starring role that he and his allegedly “teeny-tiny” penis play in the episode. The whole thing capped one of the most
contentious talent negotiations I’ve ever covered—and a possible indicator of how Ellison & Co. plan to approach deals at New Paramount. We don’t need to rehash the sordid back-and-forth, but suffice it to say that as far back as March, Matt/Trey and the current Paramount guys thought they had a $1 billion, 10-year deal with HBO Max and a path to another nonexclusive arrangement with Paramount+. The HBO Max deal was actually at the longform papering stage. But Ellison and his deputy Jeff
Shell blocked it, as was their right, and later started negotiating their own version of a preferred, lower-stakes deal. (Two sources who spoke with Ellison during this time say he spent a good deal of their conversations complaining about McCarthy and Hill-Edgar; I doubt either is getting invited to Lanai any time soon.)
Ellison initially offered South Park only a three-year extension for Paramount+, per one source familiar with the talks. Matt and Trey, via their
lawyer Kevin Morris, went nuclear, claiming Ellison was repeatedly trying to lower the market value of South Park so he could exploit it more cost-effectively on the platform he owns, even if it meant less money for Park County, Paramount’s 50-50 joint venture with Matt/Trey. Litigator Bryan Freedman got involved, and a wild period of screaming phone calls, threatening letters, and cameos from Netflix and Warner Bros. Discovery executives ensued.
Ted Sarandos courted Ellison at Sun Valley with a $275 million-a-year exclusive offer, and David Zaslav and his HBO Max team were trying as late as last weekend to get nonexclusive rights (and to include a settlement of litigation over South Park “specials” in the deal), with Matt and Trey even offering to contribute $60 million to bridge the gap.
Ellison, advised by Shell and incoming TV chief Cindy Holland, ultimately decided
to keep South Park to himself, though he could still sublicense part of the library to other platforms. The global Paramount+ deal is valued at $300 million a year for five years. Plus, after initially telling Morris that he didn’t even want to discuss a renewal of the Stone/Parker overall deal, which isn’t up until 2027, Ellison agreed to a $250 million-a-year extension for five years. Morris also wanted a huge advance, partly because the guys had taken out a loan from Carlyle that
needed to be repaid. Ari Emanuel got involved (he advises Ellison, and WME reps Matt and Trey), and they settled on a compromise of a faster recoupment instead. That paved the way for a deal to be announced Wednesday and the now-famous episode to air as planned that night.
All 26 seasons of South Park will disappear from HBO Max on August 5, and Ellison will see if a property that has consistently performed on whatever service that hosts it, including HBO Max over the past five
years, will help Paramount+ lure and retain subscribers. South Park is the 20th-most-watched streaming show of 2025 through June, according to Nielsen, with close to 10.5 billion minutes viewed on HBO Max. For context, Friends (17th place) amassed 11.4 billion minutes, and the most-streamed show on the platform, The Big Bang Theory, generated 16.6 billion minutes watched. And neither of those shows is producing 10 new episodes a year for the next five years.
|
Will Smith and What’s Next
|
Given the F.C.C. order, the Paramount transaction should sail to a close as early as August 7. (That date was
moved up from August 12.) McCarthy jumped ship today, giving the greenlight for the trades to announce his exit before he could be pushed. He’s known for months, as you and I have, that there’s no role for him at the new company, and the South Park situation didn’t help his cause. If he goes to a rival streamer, it’ll be fascinating to see if Taylor Sheridan eventually follows. McCarthy is not generally well-liked by talent, but Sheridan has been given basically
everything he wants to make his chart-topping shows, and Holland has telegraphed that changes are coming.
As I’ve noted, everything is on the table at New Paramount, and the Skydance team will finally be able to implement plans that have been sitting idle for nearly a year. The promised $2 billion in cost savings will result in far fewer employees. The cable networks are officially for sale or will be shipped off to Versant-land. CBS will almost certainly air fewer scripted programs, and
Holland wants to reduce the cost of many of the shows they do make. CBS News will be tweaked under David Rhodes and Bari Weiss, if Ellison can close those deals. Paramount+ and Pluto TV are likely to merge, resulting in big cost reductions.
At the same time, Ellison is planning to announce a slew of new additions as soon as the acquisition closes. I’m told that one of the first moves is a big overall deal with Will Smith and his Westbrook to make films
for Paramount—finally, some good news for Westbrook and Candle Media, which owns a stake, after The Slap significantly hurt that business. Smith might be banned from the Oscars until 2032, but as far as Ellison is concerned, he’s back. (A rep for Smith and Westbrook declined to comment.)
Beyond that, all eyes in Hollywood are now on Ellison and his first moves at the studio once the deal closes. Is the contentious fight behind South Park a sign of how New Paramount will treat its
biggest talent partners? Now that Holland has committed $1.5 billion to one show, will it impact her budget elsewhere? Will Trump leave Ellison and Paramount alone, even if The Daily Show or 60 Minutes or South Park continues to attack? I, for one, can’t wait until next week’s episode.
|
See you Monday,
Matt
Clarification: On Monday, I jabbed Peacock for raising prices and
forcing Bravo fans to pay for the NBA and other sports they don’t watch. Turns out Peacock just launched a “Select” tier with next-day NBC and Bravo shows (no sports) for $7.99/month. Smart!
Got a question, comment, complaint, or suggestions for Skydance-related South Park characters? Email me at
Matt@puck.news or call/text me at 310-804-3198.
|
|
|
Puck fashion correspondent Lauren Sherman and a rotating cast of industry insiders take you deep behind the scenes of this
multitrillion-dollar biz, from creative director switcheroos to M&A drama, D.T.C. downfalls, and magazine mishaps. Fashion People is an extension of Line Sheet, Lauren’s private email for Puck, where she tracks what’s happening beyond the press releases in fashion, beauty, and media. New episodes publish every Tuesday and Friday.
|
|
|
The industry’s go-to source for unflinching reporting on the trillion-dollar business of artificial intelligence - perhaps the
single most important technology of our time. Ian Krietzberg, the powerhouse journalist behind The Deep View, delivers twice-weekly insights into the latest dealmaking and breakthroughs in A.I., and how the intersecting worlds of finance, entertainment, media, and politics are being transformed in its wake.
|
|
|
Need help? Review our FAQ page or contact us for assistance. For brand partnerships, email ads@puck.news.
You received this email because you signed up to receive emails from Puck, or as part of your Puck account associated with {{customer.email}}. To stop receiving this newsletter and/or manage all your email preferences, click here.
|
Puck is published by Heat Media LLC. 107 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10006
|
|
|
|