Substack’s Influencer Allure

Molly Sims, Marlien Rentmeester
ShopMy has become the preferred platform partner for many Substack creators—including Marlien Rentmeester, right—largely because brands like Khaite, Dôen, and Prada all work with it. Photo: Jason Lowrie/BFA.com
Sarah Shapiro
December 9, 2025

Join Puck to listen to this article

It seems like the only community not questioning Substack these days is fashion influencers, who are seemingly making more money than ever. At the same time, to hear some tell it, they’re relying less on Instagram to do so. The handful I’ve spoken to in recent weeks have migrated much of their affiliate-revenue efforts to the newsletter platform out of frustration with Instagram’s algorithm, which they say has a habit of unexpectedly shifting the kinds of content the app favors. (A source at Instagram said the company hasn’t recently made major changes to the algorithm, but that posters may have experienced decreased reach as more users have joined the platform.)